Pickle logoCase Study

How Shop on Pickle 3x'd conversions and cut signup costs in half in 3 weeks

3x
Conversion rate lift
Across Flint landing pages
50%+
Lower cost per conversion
Across paid search campaigns
1 week
Time to launch
With 3 hours of team time
Natalie Dowd

"The turnaround time between getting enrolled in Flint and launching our first page took about 1 week. We couldn't have done this with a manual AI tool or without engineering support. With Flint, pages can go live same day."

Natalie Dowd·Senior Growth Marketer, Pickle

Scale your landing pages with Flint.

Trusted by fast-moving companies

Get started
Company
Pickle
Industry
Peer-to-peer fashion marketplace
Company Size
High-growth marketplace
Pain Point
Custom landing pages required manual AI work and engineering tickets, making message-matched paid search campaigns impossible to run at scale.
Solution
Google Ads landing pages,Seasonal campaigns,Google Ads optimization
About the Company
Pickle is a peer-to-peer fashion marketplace for renting and buying clothing for weddings, vacations, bachelorettes, festivals, holidays, and every occasion in between.

The Challenge

Google Search was static because pages could not scale

Before Flint, Pickle sent paid search traffic to its homepage or category pages. The team wanted every landing experience to match the ad and keyword intent, but the operational overhead made that impossible across a marketplace with countless occasions and use cases.

The old workflow started with marketing writing copy and briefing an AI tool. Generated HTML then became an engineering ticket, and every messaging test meant another ticket and another wait. A custom page could take three days of manual AI work before engineering time was even counted.

"The best experience for a prospecting customer is to have the landing experience match what they're expecting from the ad copy. But this is something that's really hard to do at scale, especially with Pickle where there are so many use cases for rental and purchase."

Natalie Dowd, Senior Growth Marketer, Pickle

The cost-benefit equation broke down for smaller campaigns. Without a scalable system, Pickle would have had to keep Google Search static or invest in building and maintaining an in-house solution.

The Solution

Two custom landing pages launched in one week

Pickle connected its Google Ads account to Flint and launched custom landing pages for wedding occasions and dress rental. The two pages targeted four ad groups and went live within one week.

Onboarding required about three hours of team time to teach Flint Pickle's brand, design preferences, and messaging. The team could then create and publish new pages without waiting on engineering.

"Now that Flint knows our brand, we can create custom landing pages even for campaigns spending just $15 per week. Before, the cost-benefit equation wasn't there."

Natalie Dowd, Senior Growth Marketer, Pickle

Flint also removed the need for design sprints, a separate landing page builder and hosting setup, manual ad rewrites, URL swaps, and an external paid search agency.

3x conversions and more than 50% lower acquisition costs

Within two to three weeks, Flint landing pages delivered a 14 percentage point conversion increase over Pickle's homepage and a 3x stronger conversion rate overall.

Paid search cost per conversion fell by more than 50%. Ad quality scores also improved because each page matched its ad copy and keyword intent.

"The lower you're able to acquire customers, the more spend you're able to put behind something in a really efficient way. That's what's unlocked for us."

Brian McMahon, Founder, Pickle

The lower cost per signup changed the economics of the channel. Pickle could confidently increase spend while preserving efficiency.

The unexpected win: Google Ads recommendations

Beyond landing pages, Flint surfaced practical opportunities in Pickle's Google Ads account. Recommendations identified keyword gaps such as unexpected demand for night-out searches, negative keywords that were bleeding budget, and messaging gaps between ads and landing pages.

Instead of defaulting to recommendations to spend more, Flint gave the team specific ways to improve campaign efficiency and capture overlooked demand.

"We're now opening up a new channel for us. Flint's allowed us to actually use this as a new channel and a new tool in our tool belt."

Brian McMahon, Founder, Pickle

The Bottom Line

From set it and forget it to a scalable growth channel

Pickle turned Google Search from a static campaign into a core growth channel. The team plans to scale spend on high-performing campaigns, launch seasonal pages for holidays and events, expand into paid social, and use self-optimization as spend grows.

For a consumer marketplace with endless use cases and short seasonal windows, launching message-matched pages in days instead of weeks has made profitable iteration possible.

"All I care about is performance. ROI has been great so far, and as long as the results continue, we have no complaints."

Natalie Dowd, Senior Growth Marketer, Pickle
Pickle rented bridal looks landing page
Pickle lehenga and sari rental landing page
Pickle trending dress rental landing page
Pickle rented bridal looks landing page
Pickle lehenga and sari rental landing page
Pickle trending dress rental landing page
Pickle rented bridal looks landing page
Pickle lehenga and sari rental landing page
Pickle trending dress rental landing page
Pickle rented bridal looks landing page
Pickle lehenga and sari rental landing page
Pickle trending dress rental landing page
Pickle rented bridal looks landing page
Pickle lehenga and sari rental landing page
Pickle trending dress rental landing page

Scaling Spend Shouldn't Scale Your CAC

Book a demo and we'll scope a pilot on your site. Real pages, your campaigns, measurable results before any commitment.

  • Start with a risk-free pilot
  • A dedicated expert on your account
  • Ships on your own domain
  • No engineering required

See Flint on your pages